Council for Countering Online Disinformation Research, public affairs, thought leadership, consulting and media literacy

CCOD Statement on the Government's U16s Social Media Ban

Today the Government announced its decision to implement a social media ban for under-16s, broadly modelled on the Australian approach. The CCOD has engaged extensively with this policy debate, including through its submission to DSIT's Growing Up in the Online World consultation, the publication of our paper ‘Should the UK Ban Social Media for Under-16s?’ and through a panel event convened at the London School of Economics.

Our position is clear, and today's announcement does not change it: a ban is the wrong answer to the right question.

Commenting on today's announcement, the CCOD's Executive Director Thomas Barton states, "The CCOD has expected for several months that the Government would introduce a version of the Australian ban of social media for under sixteens. This was inferred from the political support in Parliament for such a move given pressure from parents who overwhelmingly support the ban, combined with statutory legislation being introduced to pave the way for a ban prior to the Government's conclusion of the consultation process. While the Government is entirely right to focus its energy on combatting online threats and include the imposition of tough measures on online platforms to achieve that end, a blanket ban on social media use will fail to yield well-intended results.

A social media ban creates an arbitrary cliff edge at sixteen, and the Australian experience demonstrates that enforcement remains highly challenging. Most importantly though, an outright ban wrongly shifts the onus onto children and families, and let's social media platforms off the hook. The most appropriate way of protecting young people from online harms including disinformation is through delivering safety-by-design changes to how social media platforms operate.

The CCOD has long called for user empowerment tools, far greater action on combatting bot accounts, and algorithmic transparency and re-design to sit alongside media literacy initiatives and innovative AI detection technology for identifying and combatting online disinformation. Now that a social media ban will be introduced, it is important that the Government treats this policy as an emergency brake. Social media platforms should be compelled to introduce a range of measures that will effectively tackle online threats including disinformation. The Government should consider creating an incentive-based framework, whereby the ban is lifted for compliant and responsible platforms willing to adopt the necessary measures for combatting online threats.

Myself and the CCOD Board will continue to work constructively and collaboratively with parliamentarians and civil society organisations to ensure the UK urgently seizes the opportunity afforded by the introduction of the ban to meaningfully tackle online disinformation and clean up online platforms. The time for proper action is now."

The CCOD welcomes the principle of the Government wanting to act to increase online safety but remains concerned that a social media ban does not contribute to this aim. The evidence from Australia strongly supports our position. Four months after implementation, 61% of 12 to 15-year-olds retained access to restricted platforms because the ban was routinely failed to be enforced. The Government states it will introduce highly effective age assurance measures (HEAA) to address this gap. That is welcome, but it rests on a flawed assumption. The problem in Australia was not a lack of technical tools; it was a lack of platform accountability. Without a fundamental shift in how obligations are placed on platforms, there is no reason to expect a different outcome in the UK.

The scope of today's announcement is broader than a social media ban alone.

The inclusion of harmful functions such as livestreaming and stranger communication across gaming platforms and other online environments is a step the CCOD has long advocated. We have consistently argued that regulating social media in isolation while leaving adjacent digital environments unaddressed simply displaces risk rather than eliminates it. The Australian evidence highlights this: 43% of children subject to the ban increased their use of gaming platforms, and 39% increased their use of messaging applications. Therefore, a more joined-up approach to platform regulation is the right instinct.

We also welcome the Government's recognition of the cliff-edge problem at 16, and its intention to introduce default restrictions for under-17s. This is a sensible acknowledgement that abrupt exposure at a threshold age is not a coherent online safety strategy. However, this should be addressed with more effort, rather than simply proposing unclear restrictions which lasts only one year after meeting the threshold age and with no prior effort.

On AI, the announcement rightly addresses romantic companion chatbots and intimate functionalities on AI platforms. These are real risks, and minimum age thresholds are a reasonable starting point. But they are insufficient. AI is simultaneously one of the most significant threats to the online information environment and one of the most powerful tools available to address it. AI-generated content, AI-driven algorithmic curation, and AI-enabled disinformation must be treated as a central pillar of online safety policy, not as a footnote.

The CCOD's fundamental concern with the ban remains unchanged.

A social media ban transfers the burden of responsibility to young users rather than to the platforms whose design choices generate the harm. Platforms could use the existence of a ban as cover to avoid meaningful reform, while their environments remain polluted with disinformation, manipulative algorithms, and unmoderated content. When young people reach the threshold age, they will encounter those environments without preparation, having been excluded rather than equipped.

Social media has become a primary arena for news consumption and civic engagement among younger generations. Ofcom data shows that TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram are now the leading sources of news for 12 to 15-year-olds. Exclusion is not protection. What is needed is a combination of two things: equipping young people with the skills to navigate these environments critically, and improving those environments from within through platform and algorithmic accountability.

This is why the CCOD calls on the Government to implement the following measures:

Structured media literacy, embedded in national curriculum design from primary school onwards and extended to adults and workforces. Children model adult behaviour. Targeting only young people without addressing the habits of the adults around them is insufficient.

User empowerment features, through amendments to the Online Safety Act placing a duty on platforms to provide simple, user-controlled toggles to filter AI-generated content and material that does not meet basic standards of factual accuracy. Platforms should be required to give users meaningful control over their own feeds.

Mandatory AI watermarking, making AI-generated content identifiable at source. Technical solutions such as Adobe's C2PA already exist. The EU and California have already implemented comparable requirements. The UK is behind.

Algorithmic design accountability, including safeguards to limit the amplification of false content during public order crises, and mechanisms to prioritise Public Service Broadcaster content in users' feeds when harmful disinformation is spreading at pace.

The CCOD supports the Government's intention to act. Public concern about the online environment is legitimate and has reached a tipping point that elected representatives are right to take seriously. But decisive action and effective measures are different things. The hard work, reforming platform design, enforcing algorithmic accountability, and building genuine digital resilience, is less publicly visible than a ban and considerably more difficult, but it is what the UK needs to implement to seriously face the online disinformation challenge.

The CCOD will continue to work with a cross-party group of parliamentarians on effective policy measures for combating online threats including through meaningful and comprehensive regulation of online social media platforms.

Related

All news