Council for Countering Online Disinformation Research, public affairs, thought leadership, consulting and media literacy

CCOD Statement on Proposed Social Media Ban for Under-16s

The CCOD welcomes the Government's shift to a more robust regulation of tech platforms, as highlighted by the action taken against Grok and now the decision to consult on a ban for social media for under 16s.

On the proposed social media ban, the CCOD believes it will not have the desired effect and risks diluting efforts to fight disinformation.

An Australian-style blanket ban, like the one being proposed, would merely postpone the effects of disinformation-polluted online spaces on young people, avoiding the root cause. While we recognise the harmful effect social media can have on young people, removing access altogether does not empower teens to learn the discernment skills they need to navigate social media into adulthood.

An outright ban would also create a sharp cliff edge moment at 16. With 16-year olds now enfranchised, there is a real risk of holding teens in a media blackout up until the moment they can vote. Indeed, recent data from Ofcom shows that 57% of 12-15 year olds consume news on social media.

There are many alternatives to a ban. More nuanced approaches are already being rolled out, including severely limiting smartphone access in schools as well as the forthcoming changes to media literacy announced in the Government's Curriculum and Assessment review.

Blunt instruments like this proposed ban penalise teens without placing the proper onus on social media companies to make their online spaces safer and better regulated. There is lots more we can do in this regard. A suggestion the CCOD has already championed, for example, would be mandating social media companies include 'user empowerment' toggles in filtered feeds. These in-built features would encourage and teach all users - adults and teens - to take greater control over their social media diets by allowing them to 'filter out' particular types of content that are AI generated or that do not meet international journalistic standards on factual accuracy.

The CCOD believes the best approach to protect young people online remains one centred around Innovation, education, and regulation. In the short term, supporting the ecosystem of private providers working on AI-powered disruption. In the medium term, advocating for pragmatic policy and regulatory interventions to limit the spread of disinformation. In the long term, pushing for educational interventions, both for children and working-age people, to foster media literacy and discernment skills.

The CCOD continues to constructively engage with Government and parliamentarians on the most appropriate policy measures for mitigating the growing threat of AI-powered disinformation harming young people in Britain today.

Related

All news