CCOD Statement on Gov Response to DSIT Report
Despite being published over a month past its deadline, the CCOD is pleased to see that the government has responded to the DSIT’s report on ‘social media, misinformation and harmful algorithms’.
The report contains valuable collated evidence from the public, major tech companies, regulators and experts on digital fact-checking, online safety, and digital advertising. It also sets out a series of recommendations that the UK government is legally required to consider and respond to. The CCOD supports the DSIT in spotlighting the rapidly evolving disinformation landscape, the Online Safety Act’s inadequacy in addressing its spread, and the necessity for a more coordinated response.
We welcome the government’s agreement with much of the sentiment of the DSIT report and their recognition of the problems raised. Their response clearly reiterates that “the government is committed to a safer online world and we urge providers to counter the spread of mis- and disinformation on their services. The government recognises that online misinformation has the potential to cause real-world impacts and undermine public trust in the information environment” (p. 6). We are also pleased to see acknowledgement of the complexity of the issue at hand, as well as the necessity of its balance with freedom of expression.
However, we also share the committee's frustration; the government and Ofcom’s responses fall short of accepting many recommendations despite agreement with their sentiments.
The CCOD takes the stance that simply “[urging] providers to counter the spread of mis- and disinformation on their services” isn’t enough, though this seems to be a repeated theme of the government’s current approach. The government passes many of their responses to Ofcom, hesitant to consider further action against disinformation that isn’t advisory.
Despite the government’s assurance in this response that there is a unified, organised approach to combatting mis- and disinformation, disparities are emerging between the sentiments of government and Ofcom. This includes a disagreement regarding whether AI-generated content is covered by the Online Safety Act (2023). The CCOD will release further analysis of this disconnect on Monday.
Furthermore, upon not accepting almost all of the DSIT’s recommendations, the government fails to provide alternative solutions to the problems they acknowledge exist. We need the government to take this evolving threat to information integrity seriously through considering holistic action in the form of immediate effective AI detection solutions, actionable regulatory change, and the longer term benefits of comprehensive media literacy education.
The CCOD will continue to raise these important issues in our ongoing engagement with policymakers and government, and will continue to represent and work with our growing ecosystem of organisations and actors committed to addressing the disinformation threat.