In light of Andy Burnham’s cabinet reshuffle, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) will be abolished. This presents a critical opportunity for counter-disinformation policy. The CCOD believes that the time to act on disinformation is now. We want a government that is focused on the task of delivering policy and regulatory reform needed to protect the UK from the rising tide of AI-driven disinformation threats. Organisational changes across Whitehall to the machinery of government must not serve as a distraction from the important focus of advancing online safety and addressing online threats including disinformation. Fundamentally important policy areas of technology, online safety, and the information environment must continue to be represented at Cabinet and prioritised across government. DSIT provided a necessary home for these policy areas and brought much needed expertise, but the CCOD has been concerned that the different elements of counter disinformation policy were assigned to alternative government departments, leaving DSIT with little influence to advance solutions on the issue.
The CCOD believes that further fragmentation of these policy areas across multiple different departments will lead to an even less-joint up approach for counter disinformation policy than previously. DSIT has been carved up between the expanded Department of Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, and the Cabinet Office. The CCOD retains its concerns as this lack of coordination has been exacerbated by the changes and risks a lengthy period of reorganisation at a time when direction is needed on this critical national issue. Therefore, it is even more pressing to establish some form of government taskforce or unit to coordinate counter disinformation policy across Whitehall, as proposed by RUSI and supported by the Foreign Affairs Select Committee. A combination of platform regulation, education-based approaches, and private sector innovation are needed in tandem to protect the UK from disinformation threats. The changes to the Whitehall machinery with DSIT’s abolition present an opportunity to reform the approach to countering disinformation with a new body, and ensure all these approaches are coordinated effectively to tackle disinformation.
However, the CCOD welcomes the clearer separation between platform regulation and attracting big-tech investment. DSIT had a conflict of interest built into its mandate, acting as cheerleader for big-tech investment, including from US tech giants, while also being responsible for online safety and counter disinformation policy, which requires greater regulation of tech platforms. The CCOD continues to advocate for a holistic approach on this, championing solutions across innovation, regulation, and education. Businesses and citizens also have a key role to play alongside the government in building resilience to disinformation threats as part of a whole-of-society approach.
The CCOD recognises the leadership DSIT has demonstrated on AI, a transformative emerging technology capable of, within the right regulatory framework, positively transforming lives. In our own counter disinformation space we have seen the power of innovative AI technology developed by homegrown British start-ups for purposes of combatting disinformation and protecting online information integrity. The decision for the AI minister to attend Cabinet provides an opportunity to continue to promote innovation-based solutions as a cutting-edge approach; using sovereign AI capability harnessed by British innovators for purposes of countering disinformation.
The CCOD will continue to engage constructively with ministers, parliamentarians and officials in Whitehall alike. We welcome the newly appointed Secretaries of State Jonathan Reynolds, Louise Haigh, Lisa Nandy and Minister of State Kanishka Narayan to their posts and look forward to working with them on the pressing issue of AI-driven disinformation.
Thomas Barton, Executive Director at the Council for Countering Online Disinformation