‘Misinformation’ and ‘disinformation’ have always been a feature of politics, dating back millennia. In the dying days of the Roman Republic and the Second Triumvirate, Octavian (later the first Roman emperor, Augustus) waged a ruthless disinformation campaign against his rival, Mark Antony, accusing him of abandoning Rome and its values in favour of Egypt and his mistress, Cleopatra. It was a propaganda war utilised so effectively by Octavian that it decisively turned the Roman public and senate against his arch-rival.
Nearly 2,000 years later, and whilst fake news and the manipulation of the truth are still a prominent part of society, the form and structure of disinformation have changed. With the dawn of the internet, social media and generative AI, disinformation has become more pervasive and persuasive than ever before. It is for this reason that the World Economic Forum labelled disinformation as one of the top threats to global human development for the next two years.
In the realm of politics, disinformation can be used to mislead voters, smear political and public figures, undermine faith in democracy, and demoralise democratic populations to serve the interests of those who deploy it. Clare Rewcastle Brown, a prominent journalist and member of the CCOD Advisory Board, is the focus of this written interview. After she uncovered the Malaysia Development Berhad scandal, Clare became the target of a coordinated smear campaign aimed at discrediting her revelations. Given her firsthand experience, the CCOD asked Clare for her insights.
Q: How do political leaders and parties use disinformation for their own gain?
Propaganda is the primary tool for gulling the public and gaming the democratic system, and in many ways, there is nothing new about it. However, the professionalisation of politics and the evolution of a whole industry of strategists, consultants, and promoters means there is a new level of deliberate dishonesty that has developed in Western media messaging over the past few decades.
I have acquired promotional materials that show how some consultants frankly recommend themselves to their political clients by boasting about their ability to influence public opinion by exploiting regulatory weaknesses and twisting the facts. Big money has been invested in buying platforms and developing narratives to create a popular following for actors who serve the same big money interests, when often those narratives have little to do with the real purpose behind the drive to marshal votes.
The development of those narratives primarily relies on replacing genuine news and information with partisanship, gross exaggeration, and hyperbole, combined with a refusal to inject balance, facts-based material, or opposing arguments. These requirements were baked into the licensing conditions for the broadcast media that developed following the end of the Second World War and were informed by Nazi and Soviet propaganda tactics of that era. However, the new online environment was allowed to develop without such constraints, thanks to careful lobbying primarily in the US. Key platforms, therefore, are being bought up by big money and turned into the sort of propaganda machines (through major platforms and infiltrating social media) that the likes of Goebbels and Stalin would have delighted in, producing hugely damaging outcomes in terms of popular understanding and the stability of our democracies.
Q: What forms does political disinformation take?
The purpose of disinformation is to create anger, fear, outrage, and partisanship towards certain figures or groups and to make its victims believe that the actors spreading it will solve their problems. The disinformation being spread will be visceral and expressed in simple terms that people can identify with, such as protecting their families, communities, jobs, culture, and way of life against perceived threats. Urgency is also projected. Religion, social status, and economic security are typically depicted as under threat. Perceived scroungers or incomers seeking to steal benefits owed to existing community stakeholders are portrayed as being encouraged by political opponents, without context or counterbalance. The agenda beneath such propaganda, which is to entrench certain interests in powerful positions and ensure economic opportunities for the wealthy backers of such populism, is disguised by the pitched urgency of the propaganda threats. For years, the danger of this form of extreme populism and aggressive propaganda was recognised and addressed through light-touch regulation of mass media in most post-war democracies. This media ecosystem, however, has been replaced by an unregulated online media.
Q: What role does social media play in amplifying or curbing political disinformation?
Social media is the ultimate expression of deregulation using webs of communication hosted by virtually unsupervised platforms. It is the perfect tool for those who desire to spread panic and lies under the guise of individual freedom of expression. As we know, there is major malign investment in algorithms and AI to spread disinformation and cause social disruption. This is seen as a highly effective destabilisation tactic for those who wish ill to our democracies and those irresponsible enough to do whatever damage is necessary to social cohesion to achieve power or earn consultancy fees.
Q: Which political figures or global leaders are most responsible for propagating disinformation, and why?
The abusers of disinformation are typically practitioners of populism. There are several in this business who bypass the democratic political establishments across Europe, the US, and beyond to create mass movements using the increasingly deregulated media environment. This, however, does not exonerate those same political establishments, whose failures arguably paved the way for their rejection by exasperated voters or a new voter category of previous non-voters. Neither are established political parties and actors untainted by the temptations of disinformation tactics themselves. However, they became established primarily in the context of specific ground rules and requirements to provide reasonable truth, balance, and moderation under previous forms of regulated media, and are still expected to act in accordance with them. The well-funded, newly emergent populist leaders and parties, however, abide by no such constraints, and until the consequences of such irresponsibility become clear or checked, there will always be those who choose to assume they are telling the truth.
Q: What can traditional media do to hold politicians to account for spreading disinformation?
If one were to walk the length of Fleet Street, it is notable that there is no longer a single copy of a printed newspaper on sale. The same industry is struggling to find its customers online. The newspaper industry has a history of dishonesty and partisanship, but competing publications once balanced this in the context of a mass broadcast audience. Now, however, most news consumers do not even turn to television. If they do, a growing number of newly licensed big-money-funded TV platforms cater to the same populist tactics. Regulators are cowed by well-funded and aggressive pushback. The key to addressing this problem is increasing public awareness of the dynamics behind online disinformation and TV propaganda.
Q: What can governments and/or regulatory bodies do to tackle this issue more broadly?
The problem needs to be identified and addressed as an issue. Hundreds of millions are being invested to fund disinformation and populist campaigns designed to undermine our democracies and create discord for various hidden agendas that diverge significantly from the interests of the wider public. Angered by past failings of the West’s various democratic political establishments, voters are turning to alternatives that may not have their best interests at heart and exist to serve ulterior motives. This situation needs to be called out, countered, and regulated against, which demands a determined effort by the current political establishment, that otherwise faces being replaced by dangerous and destabilising forces if the matter is left unaddressed as a point of urgency.