Council for Countering Online Disinformation Research, public affairs, thought leadership, consulting and media literacy

Fortifying Freedom: Implications of the UK-US Technology Prosperity Deal on Combatting Transnational Disinformation

Thursday’s UK-US Technology Prosperity Deal (TPD) promises to “usher in the next Golden Age of Innovation to fortify freedom and prosperity for generations to come.” It confirms a collaboration of resources between the United States and the United Kingdom to advance technological and scientific innovation. One of three key focus areas aims to accelerate AI innovation, which is expected to improve the lives of citizens and, notably, collective security in both nation-states. However, with the Trump administration reluctant to regulate information integrity, citing restoring free speech and ending federal censorship through their January Presidential Action, and much of the deal reliant on ‘shared’ or ‘mutual’ interests, questions remain about how the TPD impacts the future of disinformation regulation both transnationally and in the UK. So, post-deal, how does Trump and Starmer’s latest collaboration affect efforts to combat what the World Economic Forum ranked as the most severe risk facing the world over the next two years: disinformation?

Addressing Pre-deal Concerns

Following UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s previous acknowledgement at the Liaison Committee that “questions about how technology impacts free speech” had arisen in discussions of a UK-US trade deal, there was a growing fear that UK legislation, such as the 2023 Online Safety Act (OSA), would be watered down to accommodate the Trump administration’s position. The OSA stands to improve the regulation of online social platforms, predominantly to protect children from harm. Whilst the CCOD has its critiques of the Act, the OSA introduced new requirements for platforms to regulate and handle false content intended to cause harm, and legally required Ofcom to establish an advisory committee on disinformation and misinformation: the Online Information Advisory Committee.

Concerns were that if the OSA was diluted to accommodate Trump’s stance on regulating harmful or false content there would have been an increase in harmful content, particularly targeting children, due to a loss of regulatory legal obligations for social media platforms, and greater difficulty advocating for further attempts to combat mis- and disinformation. However, as of Thursday, it appears that the deal was signed without any amendment to the Online Safety Act.

Where are we now?

To clarify our central question (how does the UK-US Technology Prosperity Deal affect efforts to combat disinformation?), consider the following points:

1.       The deal is set to reduce friction between the US and UK tech ecosystems, opening discussions regarding data sharing and potentially smoother regulatory pathways. With disinformation being a challenge that transcends borders, this potential for transnational discussion is integral. The formation of a Ministerial Level Working Group, operative within 12 months and subsequently meeting each year, promises to set opportunities for collaboration.

2.       The political misalignment between the US and UK, however, will almost certainly make collaborative progress in combatting disinformation difficult. We can expect that, instead, identifying “shared” priorities will take up much of the discussion. Starmer commented on free speech on Thursday, indicating that whilst he is a protector of free speech, he draws a line at harmful content aimed at children. In addition, so far we’ve seen that the UK has not compromised this approach, maintaining the OSA’s integrity, which is promising for the UK information integrity space moving forward. It does, however, ask the question of where a compromise could be found between the US and UK.

3.       Despite a significant priority for innovation in the deal being information security, and research security more specifically, the TPD doesn’t mention disinformation or information integrity directly at all. The deal as a whole, including the ‘Foundations for Frontier Innovation’, appears to protect unreleased technology and research with a focus on mitigating foreign threats to projects before their release. Currently, it mirrors the Online Safety Act in focusing on international actors, failing to fully consider internal risks.

4.       While the deal omits any mention of disinformation, the focus on security could provide scope to introduce discussion of it - politics allowing. The nature of these discussions is currently unknown, but we do know from Starmer’s aforementioned comments that they have already arisen.

5.       The MOU for the TPD names science agencies within the US and UK that will be collaborating in Flagship Research Programs in “joint priority areas” of AI innovation. Upon exploring these companies’ stances, it is clear they mirror their respective state’s views on free speech, and that we can anticipate conflict of interest. The US National Science Foundation (NSF) deprioritised research aimed at combatting mis- and disinformation at the beginning of this year, subsequently cancelling active grants in these areas. It was also reported that the US National Institute of Health (NIH) terminated disinformation research funding in March despite having funded research into health misinformation in 2022. Their director has even previously stated that “if you favor government control of misinformation, you are an enemy of free speech”. Meanwhile, UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) has both funded disinformation research and published guidance around managing the risks of harmful research dissemination and information misuse.

6. Alongside the TPD came a £150 billion investment from US companies into the UK, with the intention of boosting growth and creating jobs. It’s important to note that much of this investment comes from the US’s big technology companies, who actively want and would benefit from the watering down of the Online Safety Act, Digital Services Tax and other opportunities for deregulation. Despite the lack of acknowledgement in the MOU, we can anticipate that these huge investors will expect a return in the form of deregulation. The true impact will be revealed in time.

Moving Forward

Whilst the integrity of the Online Safety Act remains intact, and Starmer doesn’t seem to be open to compromises on the UK’s regulatory stance, the political misalignment on disinformation is clear. We must carefully track future policy trends, anticipate the difficulties of introducing disinformation into the conversation, and work without compromising the safety of UK citizens. The full ramifications of the UK-US Technology Prosperity Deal for disinformation regulation will only become clearer over time.